USB 3.0: Shaking Up the Status Quo
By Jim Choate, Agilent USB Product Manager

USB is ubiquitous. According to the USB Implementers Forum (USB-IF) the USB installed base is over 10 billion units and growing at 3+ billion units a year. That is enough to equip every man, woman and child on the planet. As if that weren't enough, with the performance enhancements in USB 3.0, the technology is likely to send other interfaces to the sidelines and accelerate its market penetration.

The new USB 3.0 standard (SuperSpeed USB) defines data transfer technology that is 10 times faster than USB 2.0. The added speed will open the door for a new round of consumer products and bring smiles to the faces of users who want to transfer large amounts of data, like multimedia content, between their portable devices. The higher-speed standard was driven by consumer demand, and from an end-user perspective, it is largely evolutionary.

However, evolutionary does not mean "ho-hum." With a data rate of 5 Gb/s and data throughput capability of greater than 200 MB/s, the USB 3.0 interface is shaking up the data transfer world. It is faster than eSATA and FireWire, and it is likely to push these interfaces to the brink of extinction.

While PCI Express® interfaces are internal buses, adapters are available that let you use this technology to transfer data from one PC to another. With the performance enhancements in USB 3.0, you can forego the adapters and transfer your data with the throughput you would get from using PCI Express. This is not to say USB 3.0 will replace PCI Express technologies — all shipping USB 3.0 hosts are currently PCI Express cards — but it highlights that USB 3.0 transfer rates give engineers in-the-box performance with a technology designed from the ground up for out-of-the-box applications.

The USB 3.0 standard is also shaking up the status quo in engineering labs. USB 3.0 architecture is fundamentally different from USB 2.0. It has a PHY layer — driven by the speed requirements — very similar to PCI Express technology. So, engineers who are experts at testing and debugging USB 2.0 technology need to learn new skills. Also, at 3.0 speeds, engineers who are steeped in the digital world have to deal with microwave effects, and they usually have no experience in the microwave realm. Digital designers now have to deal with signal path routing and impedance control, which are critical design requirements for USB 3.0. Receiver design is an order of magnitude more difficult because of the need to implement complex PLLs and active receiver equalization.

One of the biggest changes designers face is the requirement to include spread-spectrum clocking (SSC) in all USB 3.0 products. SSC is required to overcome or reduce EMI issues. For device silicon, it is difficult to implement well-controlled SSC modulation for low-cost designs.

Some motherboards improperly implement center-spread SSC clocking, which violates the USB 3.0 specification requirements. Center-spread profiles are centered on the nominal frequency and are modulated above and below by equal amounts, for example +2500/-2500 ppm. Most USB 3.0 devices are not compatible with systems that improperly implement center-spread SSC. When consumers purchase host add-in cards and add them to a system that has a noncompliant system clock, they will be disappointed.

Device vendors have identified ways to work around this issue, for example by turning off SSC. The longer-term solution is to get system vendors to ensure they follow the SSC specification requirements for PCI Express and USB 3.0. For this reason, it is important to address this issue within both the PCI Express community and the USB-IF compliance program.

Further complicating the task of designing USB 3.0-compliant devices is the standard's backward compatibility requirement. As the USB standard has evolved, its data rates jumped from 1.5 Mb/s and 12 Mb/s (USB 1.1) to 480 Mb/s (USB 2.0), and now to 5 Gb/s (USB 3.0). Because each variant of USB has its own compliance test specification, the coexistence of different data rates and signal levels significantly increases device complexity and test requirements, but allows backwards compatibility that gives consumers the flexibility to mix and match peripherals with different speeds and throughput rates. This flexibility is one of the major advantages of USB.

The 10-fold increase in data rate in the USB 3.0 standard also creates new challenges in testing the transmitter, receiver and cabling system. To test SuperSpeed transmitter compliance and channel effect, engineers need a high-bandwidth oscilloscope to measure the transmitted waveform using compliance patterns. Because of the very long channel topologies allowed for USB 3.0, engineers are required to test transmitter and receiver compliance through the long channel. This means they will be testing their PHY characteristics through 3 meters of cable and an additional length of PCB trace, 5" for the host and 11" for devices.

The goal, of course, is for the engineer's USB 3.0 product to pass the compliance tests to ensure electrical interoperability. However, passing compliance tests with one or more samples of a product is no guarantee that under different conditions or for different process corners, the product will still have no problems. Margin testing provides the additional confidence designers need.

Test and measurement companies like Agilent are critical to the testing process. We provide the instruments to ensure engineers can characterize their components and devices according to the standard. In many cases, we also help them with the methodology for conducting their tests. We not only sell a box, we also help them characterize their devices in the best and most efficient way.

To sell a complete characterization solution, we need to understand the specification intimately. As a contributing member of the USB-IF, we not only understand the specification, we help shape it. Our involvement in these standards provides two key benefits: First, it enables us to bring the right products to the market when engineers need them. Second, with Agilent’s continuous involvement in plug-fests, workshops and seminars, we develop and adapt our solutions to evolve with the standards and compliance test requirements, giving engineers the ability to design and test their products with the highest confidence.

The migration of products to USB 3.0 will enable significant increases in performance in a bevy of electronic devices. Stringent test requirements can be met today because Agilent is ready with the required test and measurement tools to help engineers conquer these challenges and SuperSpeed their new devices to market.

AGILENT TECHNOLOGIES
www.agilent.com
Email this article to a friend!