Interference: The Creeping Menace
By Anatech Electronics

Interference has been the bane of communication system designers since the earliest days of radio. At least back then, there were fewer sources to contend with but also far fewer remedies at their disposal.


Uncertain Times for DefenseIn Defense of DARPA; Lamenting Bell Labs
By Barry Manz

A federal agency like DARPA is a sitting duck for politicians and assorted other critics. It has come up with some truly bizarre programs over years that ultimately either delivered no tangible results, were canceled before they could cause any damage, or attempted to answer questions that nobody was asking or needed answers to. Read More...


Band Reject Filter Series
Higher frequency band reject (notch) filters are designed to operate over the frequency range of .01 to 28 GHz. These filters are characterized by having the reverse properties of band pass filters and are offered in multiple topologies. Available in compact sizes.
RLC Electronics

SP6T RF Switch
JSW6-33DR+ is a medium power reflective SP6T RF switch, with reflective short on output ports in the off condition. Made using Silicon-on-Insulator process, it has very high IP3, a built-in CMOS driver and negative voltage generator.

Group Delay Equalized Bandpass Filter
Part number 2903 is a group delayed equalized elliptic type bandpass filter that has a typical 1 dB bandwidth of 94 MHz and a typical 60 dB bandwidth of 171 MHz. Insertion loss is <2 dB and group delay variation from 110 to 170 MHz is <3nsec.
KR Electronics

Absorptive Low Pass Filter
Model AF9350 is a UHF, low pass filter that covers the 10 to 500 MHz band and has an average power rating of 400W CW. It incurs a rejection of 45 dB minimum at the 750 to 3000 MHz band, and power rating of 25W CW from 501 to 5000 MHz.

LTE Band 14 Ceramic Duplexer
This high performance LTE ceramic duplexer was designed and built for use in public safety communication and commercial cellular applications. It operates in Band 14 and offers low insertion loss and high isolation to enable clear communications in the LTE network.
Networks International

See all products in this issue


September 2010

The GaAs versus GaN “War” Debunked
By Anthony Balistreri, Defense & Aerospace Marketing Director, TriQuint Semiconductor

By Barry Manz, Contributing Editor, MPDEveryone loves a contest, whether it’s competing with the house in the 1,500 casinos in the US, rooting for the home team, or watching CNN’s World Poker Tournament. The groups within the RF and microwave industry and the semiconductor sector in particular have fostered their own contests such as the competition between silicon devices and upstart GaAs devices in the 1980s. Industry prophets back then forecast doom for silicon small-signal and RF power devices, but the ultimate result was that GaAs took a big bite from silicon’s market share while leaving silicon LDMOS dominant in base station transceivers and other applications.

Today’s competition is between gallium nitride (GaN) and gallium arsenide (GaAs), with some of the industry’s clairvoyants foretelling GaN overtaking GaAs. To its credit, GaN offers exceptional power density (more power per square millimeter of die). It can operate at a higher power level at higher frequencies, and it offers higher efficiency. With attributes like these, it could be argued that GaN will be a slam dunk, replacing GaAs in the markets GaAs has served for years, if not decades. However, the results are likely to be similar as in the previous example, with each technology serving those applications to which it is best suited from a price/performance perspective.

To dispel any hint of proprietary bias, I feel compelled to point out that while TriQuint Semiconductor is known by many as a “GaAs company,” we’re also neck-deep in GaN and have leading surface acoustic wave (SAW) and bulk acoustic wave (BAW) filter portfolios as well as module expertise. We’ve spent more than a quarter century enhancing the performance of GaAs technology, which led in part to our wide selection of GaAs MMICs and world-class foundry services. However, since 1999 we have also been instrumental in the rapid development of GaN technology in partnership with universities, prime defense contractors, and US-government sponsored programs. We have been offering GaN foundry services and devices since 2008 and continue to grow a broad GaN portfolio. In May, we were selected by the US Air Force to provide GaN RF power transistor modules for UAVs. So while we’re not exactly “technology agnostic,” we are committed to ensuring the increasing performance and utility of not just GaAs, but of GaN as well.

The rise of GaN from a promising yet embryonic compound semiconductor technology with serious reliability issues has been meteoric. Dr. Mark Rosker, program manager for DARPA’s Wide Bandgap Semiconductor Technology Initiative (WBGS-RF) in which TriQuint has been a lead participant in Phases 2 and 3, pointed out in MPD’s March 2009 Military Microwave Digest supplement that at the beginning of the program (2001), “you could measure performance of the transistor and literally watch it degrade in front of you.” However in only a few years, said Rosker, “We made a 1010 improvement in operating lifetime from minutes to 107 hours”. As a result of efforts such as these, GaN RF power transistors are now de rigueur in IED jammer RF power amplifiers and other defense systems. Their use in commercial applications such as base station transceivers and hybrid line amplifiers for cable systems has been feverishly promoted as well.

GaN is not now and will not soon become a replacement for silicon or GaAs in the majority of applications. Cellular handsets, for example, are not readily able to take advantage of GaN’s benefits due to their low operating voltage. A GaN RF power transistor currently costs substantially more than a similarly sized GaAs device, although this is mitigated by the fact that fewer of them are needed to achieve a specific power level. Nevertheless, pure-play GaN-based companies are actively promoting the technology for use in commercial applications currently served by GaAs and even silicon, such as base station transceivers and hybrid amplifiers used by the millions in hybrid-fiber coax cable systems. GaN offers obvious benefits in both cases, but from the perspective of a company that offers both technologies, it seems that GaN will in the short term be a difficult sell in many commercial applications where there isn’t a strong need for significantly higher power levels. Further, competing technologies in the cellular frequency range such as LDMOS, high-voltage pHEMT, and high-voltage HBT offer high power density at competitive costs.

That’s why the first application of GaN RF power technology was in defense systems where cost was not as prominent a factor as performance. In commercial applications, acceptable performance is assumed and cost becomes the driver, which currently makes GaN less competitive than GaAs for many applications, regardless of the latter’s technical merits. GaAs benefits from decades of refinement and mass production; its performance and cost are well suited for most applications while the width and breadth of GaAs device and MMIC portfolios is immense. For these reasons, we believe that GaN and GaAs will coexist (although perhaps not peacefully from a marketing perspective) for years to come. However, as its cost decreases, GaN will be chosen more for high-power and higher frequency applications where its attributes overwhelm those of GaAs. This will increasingly occur in defense systems and eventually in many commercial applications. For functions other than power amplifiers and for low-voltage systems, GaAs will continue to dominate thanks to its long record of reliability, lower cost, wide availability, and excellent overall performance.

That’s not to say the two technologies won’t sometimes compete for the same applications, because there will always be exceptions in which a specific figure of merit for one or the other will be paramount and defy the aforementioned generalization. In addition, as the quantities of GaN devices increase and its processes evolve, manufacturing cost will tumble, narrowing the gap between the two. Regardless of the ultimate outcome, TriQuint will continue to advance the performance of incumbent and insurgent technologies to satisfy the greatest number of requirements. After all, the customer ultimately chooses which technology ‘wins,’—a market reality that best serves consumers and compels manufacturers to continually up their game.

Email this article to a friend!



You Can
Search by Number:

  All ads, articles, and products in printed issues of MPD have a number. Just look for the red arrow in the ad or at the end of the article or product description.


MMD March 2014
New Military Microwave Digest

The Design of Ultra Narrowband Amplifiers Using Small-Signal Varactor Upconverters
This paper presents a method of realizing tunable microwave amplifiers with ultra narrow bandwidths that can be less than 0.5% by the use of a varactor up-converter (UC).
Planar Monolithics

Directivity and VSWR Measurements
Return loss and VSWR measurements are complicated by the finite performance of the directional device used to measure the reflected power. The only accurate and convenient way to make return loss measurements is with a well matched high directivity directional coupler or bridge.
Marki Microwave

Switch Solutions for Systems with Low PIM Requirements
Dow-Key Microwave has invested in R&D for new RF switch products designed specifically to reduce intermodulation (IM) in coaxial switches.
Dow-Key Microwave

How to Specify RF and Microwave Filters
Covers cavity, ceramic, LC, crystal and helical filters.
Anatech Electronics

Mounting Considerations for Medium Power Surface-Mount RF Devices
Covers all factors that must be considered when mounting SMT devices.
TriQuint Semiconductor

Biasing MMIC Amplifiers
How to bias MMICs along with theory and techniques.

Home | About Us | Archives | Editorial Submissions | Media Kit (PDF) | Events | Subscribe/Renew | Contact Us
Copyright © 2011 Octagon Communication Inc. DBA MPDigest /, All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | Site Map